Toggle Side Panel

51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186

Milton, MA 02186 • Columbine Neighborhood
$1,375,000
Est. $7,318/month
4
Beds
3.5
Baths
2,411
Sq Ft
$570
Price/Sq Ft
0.19
Acres
1940
Year Built
Single Family Residence
Type
15
Days on Market
Closed Listed Sep 30, 2025 • MLS# 73384179 Copied!

About this home

When asked, “Why this house?”, the clear answer was and still is, “location”. Set in Milton’s desirable Columbine neighborhood, 51 Rustlewood offers proximity to Milton schools, Milton Academy, Turner’s Pond, and trolley access. Owners jumped right in, expanding to a rare 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home with room for all. The coveted primary suite now includes a walk-in closet and sumptuous bath, choices smart and current. Expansion came easily with a complete 3rd floor takeover, including cathedral ceilings, recessed lighting, bedroom, full bathroom, lounge area and generous storage. A flexible first-floor office easily serves as a den or 5th bedroom. The eat-in kitchen with newer stainless-steel appliances opens to a fenced backyard and brick patio, perfect for play and outdoor entertainment. A screened porch off the living room, recessed lighting, newer windows, newer roof, gas heat, wired for EV, lower level recreation space complete the picture. Now the better question is, “Why wait?”!

Property Overview

Property Type
Single Family Residence
Listing Type
For Sale
Year Built
1940
Bedrooms
4
Full Bathrooms
3
Half Bathrooms
1
Living Area
2,411 sq ft
Total Rooms
9

Sale Statistics

Sale Overview
Original List Price: $1,475,000
Final Sale Price: $1,375,000
Difference: $100,000 (-6.8%)
Performance Metrics
93.2%
List to Sale Ratio
Sold below asking price
15
Days on Market
Quick sale
Price per Square Foot Analysis
Original $/sq ft: $612
Sale $/sq ft: $570
This property sold for $570 per square foot
Sale Summary

This property sold for 6.8% below the original asking price.

With only 15 days on market, this was a quick sale compared to typical market conditions.

Facts & Features

1 Car Garage

Home Facts

Type Residential
Style Single Family Residence
Year Built 1940
Living Area 2,411 sq ft
Lot Size 0.19 acres
Bedrooms 4
Full Baths 3
Half Baths 1
Total Rooms 9

Interior

Heating Baseboard, Natural Gas
Cooling Window Unit(s)
Flooring Hardwood, Flooring - Wall To Wall Carpet, Flooring - Stone/ceramic Tile, Flooring - Hardwood, Flooring - Engineered Hardwood
Appliances Gas Water Heater, Oven, Dishwasher, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer, Plumbed For Ice Maker
Fireplace Living Room
Fireplaces 1
Basement Full, Partially Finished, Interior Entry
Laundry Electric Dryer Hookup, Washer Hookup, Sink, In Basement
Features Closet, Closet/cabinets - Custom Built, Recessed Lighting, Crown Molding, Bathroom - Full, Bathroom - Tiled With Shower Stall, Closet - Linen, Lighting - Sconce, Home Office, Bathroom, Sitting Room, Play Room

Exterior

Construction Frame
Architecture Colonial
Roof Shingle
Features Porch - Enclosed, Patio, Rain Gutters, Sprinkler System
Pool None
Spa None
Fencing Fenced/enclosed
Patio/Porch Porch - Enclosed, Patio

Parking

Garage Spaces 1
Has Garage Yes
Features Attached, Garage Door Opener, Off Street, Paved
Total Spaces 2

Utilities

Electric Circuit Breakers
Water Public
Sewer Public Sewer
Gas None
Other For Gas Range, For Electric Oven, For Electric Dryer, Washer Hookup, Icemaker Connection

Financial

Annual Tax $12,714
Assessed Value $1,146,400

Location

Loading map...

Neighborhood

Columbine Neighborhood

51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186

Milton, MA 02186

Walkability

Loading Walk Score...

Schools

School information not available

Monthly Payment Calculator

%
%
Estimated Monthly Payment $0

Payment Breakdown

Principal & Interest $0
Property Tax $1,060
Homeowners Insurance $200
PMI $0

Property History

Market Insights

6.8%
Price Range
16
Total Days on Market

Property Timeline

✓
Sold
Jul 29, 2025
$1,375,000
Property sold
Days on Market: 16
🏠
Listed for Sale
Jun 3, 2025
$1,475,000
Original listing
Agent: Julianne Bridgeman Office: Ceres Real Estate

Price & Status History

Date Event Price Change
Jun 3, 2025 New Listing Added $1,475,000 —

Market Statistics

Days on Market
15 days
Price per Sq Ft
$570

Tax History

Year Taxes Assessment
2025 $12,714 $1,146,400

Financial Details

Annual Property Tax
$12,714
Tax Year 2025
Assessed Value
$1,146,400

Listing Information

Listing Agent Julianne Bridgeman
Listing Office Ceres Real Estate
Agent MLS ID BB806563
Office MLS ID AN8832

Similar Homes

51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 1 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 2 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 3 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 4 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 5 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 6 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 7 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 8 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 9 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 10 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 11 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 12 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 13 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 14 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 15 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 16 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 17 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 18 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 19 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 20 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 21 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 22 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 23 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 24 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 25 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 26 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 27 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 28 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 29 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 30 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 31 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 32 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 33 51 Rustlewood Rd, Milton MA 02186 - Photo 34

Contact Agent

Schedule a Tour